What's the Best Bagel in Park Slope?
What's the Best Bagel in Park Slope?
Your Park Slope Bagel Shop Guide, plus a MAP of 25+ bagel shops in the area!
“What’s your favorite bagel shop in the neighborhood?”
That’s a question I was asked a few weeks ago at the 5th Ave Music and Art Stroll. A man and his elementary school-aged daughter stopped at my table to say hi and to sample the fresh carrot bread. After I explained a bit about my interviews and the section of favorite Park Slope things — like coffee shops, gift stores, takeout, and more — the man said, “What about bagels?” I admitted that I haven’t asked that specific question yet but promised to add it to my list for future interviews.
We talked in-depth about Park Slope bagels for what felt like 20 minutes, and his daughter even chimed in. Their favorite is La Bagel Delight, which is only a couple blocks from their apartment, so he said convenience plays a role too. “But it’s still the best and everyone who works there is great,” he said. “We also love Bagel Hole, but their bagels are different. They’re crispy and sort of dense.”
“Bagel Pub on 7th Ave is my favorite,” I told them. They both nodded in approval.
So, now I’m curious: What’s your take on the best bagel in Park Slope? Let us know in the comment section below. And, if you feel like sharing, what’s your go-to bagel order?
Park Slope Bagel Shop Guide
Just for fun, below is a list of all the bagel shops in Park Slope, and I put them on a MAP, so you can easily figure out how to get your next bagel fix no matter where you are in the neighborhood.
If you’re looking for bagels outside Park Slope, there’s a large section of shops listed below the Park Slope list, and those shops are on the MAP too. I’ll update this guide and map whenever I hear about a new or existing business that’s not on the list, so please let me know if I missed one.
📍400 7th Ave
📍461 5th Ave
📍106 7th Ave
📍57 7th Ave
📍287 9th St
📍339 5th Ave
📍671 Union St
📍284 7th Ave
📍453 4th Ave
Bagel Shops Near Park Slope
📍775 Franklin Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238
📍612 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215
📍223 Dekalb Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205
📍323 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
📍755 5th Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11232
📍473 Bergen St, Brooklyn, NY 11217
📍181 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
📍557 Flatbush Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11225
📍476 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11231
📍108 Montague St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
📍410 Myrtle Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11205
📍645 Vanderbilt Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238
📍136 Lawrence St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
📍663 Third Avenue, 129 20th St, Brooklyn, NY 11232
Shelsky's Of Brooklyn Appetizing and Delicatessen
📍141 Court St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
📍202 Smith St, Brooklyn, NY 11201
222 &, 222A Prospect Park West, Brooklyn, NY 11215
Your tap water might taste different for a while: The Croton Distributing Reservoir, the city’s primary water source, has been leaking 35 million gallons of drinking water EACH DAY for 30 YEARS! To fix the leak, a stretch of the Delaware Aqueduct near Newburgh will be shut down for several months. But New Yorkers still need water, so the Department of Environmental Protection is connecting a bypass tunnel, mixing in water from a different reservoir from the city’s system of 19 of them. Any difference you may notice in the water’s taste won’t be because of the bypass tunnel but rather a change in the blend of water sources during the repairs, according to DEP Commissioner Rohit Aggarwala.
Community Board 7 rejected Arrow Linen’s plan for 13- to 19-story apartment buildings: The board voted 30 to 6 to disapprove the rezoning proposal. Arrow Linen must “withdraw the application and conduct planning and visioning meetings with area residents before submitting a reworked rezoning proposal.”
10/04 Shop: Brooklyn Charm Bar, 11AM-4:30PM 📍Brooklyn Museum
10/04 Grand Opening—$3 Scoops All Day, 11:30AM-10PM 📍Heaps
10/04 90s Hip Hop Dreamland Roller Disco, 7PM-10PM 📍LeFrak Center at Lakeside
10/04 Corey O'Brien, 7:30PM 📍The Bell House
10/04 Impossible But True, 7:30PM 📍Old Stone House
10/04 Love Isn't Blind | A Comedy/Dating Show Where the Men Can't Speak, 8PM 📍Littlefield
10/05 FIDO Coffee Bark, 7:30AM-9AM 📍Long Meadow
10/05 Brooklyn Pop-Up: The Old Stone House Fall Bazaar, 10AM-5PM 📍Old Stone House
10/05 Crime and Catastrophe Trolley Tour, 10AM-12PM 📍Green-Wood Cemetery
10/05 & 10/06 Nature Exploration, 10AM-1PM 📍Audubon Center
10/05 Wake Up & Dance with Suzi Shelton, 10AM-11:30AM 📍ShapeShifter Lab
10/05 Archtober Prospect Park Tour: Calvert Vaux at 200, 10:30AM-12:30PM 📍Bartel-Pritchard Square
10/05 Prospect Park Yoga, 10:30AM 📍15th Street Entrance, Prospect Park
10/05 Brooklyn Museum Birthday Bash, 11AM-10PM 📍Brooklyn Museum
10/05 How Not to Kill Your Houseplants, 11AM-2PM📍Brooklyn Botanic Garden
10/05 Barrk & Brew Adoption Event, 12PM-4PM 📍The Commissioner
10/05 & 10/06 Museum on Wheels: Birthday Bash, 12PM-5PM 📍Brooklyn Museum
10/05 Retro Games 4 NY, 12PM-5PM 📍Park Slope United Methodist Church
10/05 Les Contes d’Hoffmann (pre-screening lecture w/Fred Plotkin, screening to follow at 1PM), 12PM 📍BAM
10/05 SPOONS TOONS ALL AGES HALLOWEEN! 12PM 📍Nitehawk Cinema
10/05 Gay Gothic: Love, Loss, and the Hereafter, 3:30PM-5:30PM 📍Green-Wood Cemetery
10/05 Lakeside Roller Dance Night FT Roller Wave, 6PM-10PM 📍LeFrak Center at Lakeside
10/05 Arden Myrin's WILL YOU ACCEPT THIS ROSE? LIVE! 7:30PM 📍The Bell House
10/05 Hoodo Hersi: EXTRAORDINARY ALIEN, 📍7:30PM Union Hall
10/05 Colonizing America Tour II with Tanael Joachim, 8PM 📍Littlefield
10/05 Party Like It’s 1999: Holy Sh*t, That Song is 25! Edition, 10PM 📍The Bell House
10/06 Birdwatching: First Sunday Outings, 8AM-10AM 📍Audubon Center
10/06 Behind the Bumps: Leaf Galls and Their Ecological Impact, 10:30AM-12PM 📍Green-Wood Cemetery
10/06 Brooklyn Pop-Up Market, 10:30AM-5:30PM 📍Brooklyn Museum
10/06 Brooklyn Museum Birthday Bash, 11AM-5PM 📍Brooklyn Museum
10/06 Park Pitch In: Street Tree Care, 11AM-2PM 📍Prospect Park
10/06 Smorgasburg, 11AM 📍Prospect Park Breeze Hill
10/06 Voices From The West Bank: Palestinian House of Friendship, 12:30PM-2PM 📍Brooklyn Society for Ethical Culture
10/06 Grand Designs: Architecture at Green-Wood Walking Tour, 2PM-3:30PM 📍Green-Wood Cemetery
10/06 DJ on the Porch: Lefferts Libations, Homage of Music and History, 2PM-7PM 📍Prospect Park, Lefferts Historic House
10/06 Lyric Masterpieces, 3PM-4:30PM 📍St. John's Episcopal Church
10/06 Edgar Allan Poe: Friends and Foes at Green-Wood Walking Tour, 3:30PM-5:30PM 📍Green-Wood Cemetery
10/06 Meat Cats Comedy Presents: Sunday Sauce, 5PM 📍Union Hall
10/06 October Happily Everyone After Book Club Brooklyn, 7:15PM-8:30PM 📍The Ripped Bodice
10/06 Mackenzie Shivers + Hallie Spoor + Captain Tallen & the Benevolent Entities, 7:30PM-10:30PM 📍Littlefield
10/07 Book Discussion: "Brother Alive" by Zain Khalid, 12PM-1PM 📍Park Slope Library
10/07 Death Cafe, 6PM-7:30PM 📍Green-Wood Cemetery
10/07 Two Authors in Four Scenes: Selva Almada and Dolores Reyes in conversation, 7PM-8:30PM 📍Central Library
10/07 The Moth StorySLAM, 7:15PM 📍The Bell House
10/07 Home Planet: 6 Short Films, 8PM-10PM 📍Littlefield
10/08 Stomp, Clap and Sing with Araceli, 10:30AM 📍Central Library
10/08 Jack and Friends Latino heritage month: Bilingual Birdies, 4PM-4:45PM 📍Park Slope Library
10/08 Turning 5 Talks, 6:30PM 📍Virtual, Brooklyn Conservatory of Music
10/08 Life Drawing October 2024, 7PM-9:30PM 📍Old Stone House
10/08 Pretty Women: A Real Housewives Musical Revue, 7PM-9PM 📍Good Judy
10/08 Translator Allison Markin Powell presents Gifted by Suzumi Suzuki, in conversation with E. Madison Shimoda, 7PM-8PM 📍Community Bookstore
10/08 Zach Zimmerman: *Special Taping*, 7:30PM & 10PM 📍The Bell House
10/08 Drag Bingo, 8PM 📍Rollo’s
10/09 Fall First Discoveries, 10:30AM-12:30PM 📍Brooklyn Botanic Garden
10/09 Arte Congo: Artists' Journey on the Congo Coast of Panamá - Film Screening and Discussion, 6PM-9PM 📍Central Library
10/09 Sally J. Pla comes to Brooklyn Public Library! 6:30PM-8PM 📍Central Library
10/09 Mortified, 8PM 📍Littlefield
10/10 Lalo-palooza with Suzi Shelton, 10AM 📍Old Stone House
10/10 Prospect Park Stroller Walk, 10AM-11AM 📍Audubon Center
10/10 BASEBALL! A Group Exhibition curated by Jonathan Blum and Eric Wolf, 6PM-10PM 📍ShapeShifter Lab
10/10 Intermediate Floral Design Series, 6PM-7:30PM 📍Brooklyn Botanic Garden
10/10 “Little Lace” Gallery Opening Reception, 6PM-8PM 📍Old Stone House
10/10 Uncropped (followed by a Q&A with James Hamilton, David Lee, Sean Corocoran and director D.W. Young), 7PM 📍Nitehawk Cinema
10/10 Mike Falzone: Surrounded, 7:30PM 📍The Bell House
10/10 Dyketopia, 8PM-10PM 📍Littlefield
Thank you so so so much for reading Park Slope Times! I love having you here. If you’re in the mood for browsing, check out my other guide on Park Slope Thrift, Vintage & Consignment Stores.
I hope you have a great weekend!
Kelley xo
As a bagel lover this is such a great resource! So many bagels… so little time.
Can’t wait to try some places we’ve never tried before.
Wow I looooove this topic! Were bagel pub regulars 😎